Saturday, February 2, 2008

Speaking Event Coverage from Jerusalem - Khaled Abu Toameh

Khaled Abu Toameh - West Bank and Gaza correspondent for the Jerusalem Post and U.S. News and World Report and a documentary filmmaker.



January 5th 2007 at the Jerusalem Gate Hotel presented by Stand With Us - Israel to a Winter 2008 Birthright group.



  • Israeli Arab, has Palestinian mother from the West Bank, born in Tulkarem in 1963

  • Worked for PLO, as reporter licensed by the Israeli government because in those days you had to work for the PLO

  • Graduated from Hebrew University, 7 years Jerusalem post

  • Foreign journalists don't face any problems in Israel, no intimidation, they can write anti-Israeli stuff

    • Journalists covering the Arab world stay in Israel

  • US journalists cant speak to Hamas

  • 20 years adviser to foreign journalists

    • NBC Palestinian Affairs producer

  • Has to work in Israeli newspapers to practice real journalism

  • No free media in Arab world

  • Palestinians got exposed to good things inside Israel

    • Hoping Arafat would set up democracy

    • Oslo implementation was bad, bad partner

    • Note: Says “we” in reference to Israel

  • Palestinians never saw the fruits of peace, Arafat stole the money

    • Built a casino opposite refugee camp

    • Gave Suha Arafat $100k a month for shopping in Paris

    • Lost faith in the process because of corruption

  • Arafat promised 100% or nothing, didn't sign anything at Camp David

  • When you ask 12 year old in refugee camp what he wants to be when he grows up, he says I want to be suicide bomber

  • In 2005 Abbas said I will fix corruption and build institutions, that was his platform, 60% gave a mandate in elections

  • More Palestinians killed in internal fighting than by Israel

    • More lawlessness

  • January 2006 Hamas ran on change and reform, appropriated Abbas' platform

    • Put Israel destruction on bottom of list of platform

    • Good governance against PLO

  • Free and democratic election went for Hamas

    • Worst violence in territories between Fatah and Hamas

    • Not between bad and good, between bad and bad

    • Fighting over money and power

  • Mistakes by us and Europe, didn't tell them to reform, gave them guns and told them to

  • “PLO can never be reformed”

  • When Palestinians saw US giving money to Fatah

  • Egypt sealed border and made Fatah knock on Israel's door, Israel saved them dumped them to West Bank

    • Hamas is a very dangerous regime, Iran is in Gaza, Syria, Lebanon

    • PLO only in west bank because of IDF

    • If he were Olmert he couldn't give any land to Abbas

    • PLO weak and corrupt, not legitimate

Question and Answer Session:

  • We don't know in west Hamas has provided social services

    • Hamas was doing what PLO should be doing

    • vote was combination between ideology and services

    • Hamas came into vacuum in Gaza

  • American influence in Arab country

    • Why doesn't the US tell gulf countries to help

    • Law in Lebanon says Palestinians cant work in 72 professions

    • In Kuwait they are banned by law from buying apartment

  • Iran

    • [In Iran] I wouldn't be standing here talking to you, [I wouldn't be allowed]

    • Ahmadinejad: Muslim Hitler

      • Will kill him [Khaled] if he speaks out against the regime

    • [Khaled] Hopes students will bring him [Admadinejad] down

  • How can we as Americans influence the situation?

    • All about education, talk to PLO demand something for your money, they are dependent

    • This generation more radical then last

Closing remarks

  • Dictators are radicalizing people

    • We are suppressing reformists



Jerusalm Gate Hotel, Jerusalem, Israel

1 comment:

Brett said...

This journalist sounded very conventional (supporter of the hawkish Israeli military regime) and by seeing who he works for - Jerusalem Post, U.S. News and World Report - it is not a big surprise. I hear the same old story in how he describes the situation: blame the Arab world and Palestinians as a stall tactic so that Israel can continue to break international law by colonizing the West Bank.
On another note, is it possible for someone to clarify some of the points he made? Some of the minutes are a little confusing.